Attorney at Law
FOR LAWYERS

A surcharge action is a legal proceeding initiated to address and rectify the breaches of duty by fiduciaries, such as trustees, executors, or personal representatives, who are responsible for managing assets on behalf of beneficiaries or estates. This legal mechanism is designed to seek redress and compensation for losses or damages incurred due to the fiduciary's failure to adhere to their obligations, including mismanagement of assets, breach of trust, or any inappropriate actions detrimental to the assets or estate they oversee. 

In the context of trust and estates, surcharge actions are not limited to financial mismanagement but extend to any action or inaction by a fiduciary that violates their duties of care, loyalty, or impartiality, thereby impacting the estate’s/trust’s value or the beneficiaries' interests negatively, including:

  • Mismanagement of Estate Assets: This type of surcharge arises when a fiduciary fails to manage the estate's assets with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances that a prudent person acting in a similar capacity would use. Examples of mismanagement include poor investment decisions, failure to collect debts owed to the estate, or selling estate assets at below-market prices.
  • Unauthorized Commingling of Funds: A surcharge may be imposed when a fiduciary mixes estate assets with their own personal assets or with assets from another estate they are managing.
  • Unauthorized Investments: Fiduciaries are typically limited by statute or the governing document (such as a will or trust) in the types of investments they can make with estate assets. Engaging in speculative, risky, or otherwise unauthorized investments that result in losses can lead to surcharges.
  • Diverting Estate Assets: Diverting estate assets involves a fiduciary improperly using the estate's property or funds for personal benefit or for the unauthorized benefit of others. This constitutes a clear breach of the fiduciary's duty of loyalty to the estate's beneficiaries.
  • Failure to Distribute Assets in a Timely Manner: Fiduciaries have a duty to distribute the assets of an estate or trust according to the terms laid out in the will or trust document. Unjustified delays or failures to distribute assets can harm beneficiaries and may result in surcharges to compensate for the delay or any losses incurred.

Common Outcomes of Surcharge Proceedings

Surcharge proceedings can result in various outcomes, including: 

  • Restitution: The most common outcome is that the fiduciary may be ordered to make restitution to the estate or trust for any losses incurred due to their mismanagement or breach of duty. This means the fiduciary has to pay back the amount lost, with possible interest.
  • Removal of the Fiduciary: A court can remove a fiduciary from its position if it finds that the fiduciary breached their duty. This is a drastic measure usually reserved for clear cases of mismanagement or misconduct.
  • Denial of Fees: Fiduciaries are typically entitled to reasonable fees for their services. However, if a surcharge proceeding finds that they acted improperly, the court may deny them these fees.
  • Fines and Penalties: In some jurisdictions, fiduciaries found to have breached their duty may also be subject to fines and penalties (in addition to restitution), especially if fraud or serious misconduct is involved.

Jurisdictional Variations

When it comes to surcharge actions, there are several jurisdictional variations worth noting. One of the most important distinctions is the basis for liability. What constitutes a breach of fiduciary duty can vary by state, and certain jurisdictions may have stricter standards for fiduciary conduct or specific guidelines about what constitutes a breach of fiduciary duties.

Another key consideration is the range of remedies provided in each jurisdiction. While restitution and removal are common, the availability of fines, penalties, and damages can differ, and some states might allow for punitive damages in cases of especially egregious conduct.

Procedural requirements for initiating surcharge proceedings and the burden of proof required to establish a breach can also vary. Some states may be more plaintiff-friendly, while others impose stricter requirements. Additionally, the statute of limitations and the appeals processes can differ, which can have a significant impact on the difficulty of pursuing a surcharge action and the potential outcome.

Ask a Lawyer

Ask your own question and get advice from expert attorneys
Ask Question

Featured Probate Litigation Lawyers

The Nordhaus Firm

google-logo
21 years in practice
Advance Healthcare Directives, Divorce & Family Law, Divorce Law, Estate Administration, Estate Planning
View Profile

Law Office of Edwin Burnett

36 years in practice
Copyright, Intellectual Property
View Profile

Aldrich & Brunot, LLC

google-logo
9 years in practice
Auto Accidents, Personal Injury
View Profile

Horn Wright, LLP

google-logo
28 years in practice
Employment Law, Personal Injury, Sexual Assault
View Profile

Contact AttorneyAtLaw.com

Are you looking for an attorney? Do you have questions about a legal case you are facing? Contact us now and we will put you in touch with a lawyer for free.
Attorney At Law is changing how clients connect with lawyers. By providing an innovative platform to lawyers who want to expand their practice’s reach, AAL is bringing law practices into the future.
6142 Innovation Way
Carlsbad, California 92009
Some of the content of this website may be considered attorney advertising under the rules of certain jurisdictions. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.
crossmenuchevron-upchevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram